New York Court of Appeals Sanctions a Plaintiff’s Attorney for Pursuing a Needless Legal Malpractice Claim

Written By: Patterson Law Firm
legal malpractice attorneys Chicago

A New York appeals court recently sanctioned a plaintiff’s attorney in a legal malpractice case as a result of the court’s finding that the legal malpractice plaintiff’s attorney continued to pursue a legal malpractice claim despite “clear evidence” from the record that the claim had no basis.

In the underlying case, the plaintiff had been pursuing several claims against individuals and a public relations firm for the mismanagement and subsequent loss of fine art that the plaintiff owned or was authorized to sell. Plaintiff initially retained attorney Eric Vaughn-Flam to pursue the claim in federal court. The relationship between plaintiff and Vaughn-Flam eventually deteriorated and resulted in Vaughn-Flam withdrawing from representing plaintiff in the federal case. Plaintiff then retained successor counsel who voluntarily withdrew some of the claims that had been alleged by Vaughn-Flam in the initial complaint and never sought a default judgment against an individual defendant who had failed to appear in the case. The case eventually settled.

The plaintiff then filed a legal malpractice claim against Vaughn-Flam in New York state court, alleging that Vaughn-Flam had voluntarily withdrawn all viable claims in the complaint. Vaughn-Flam opposed the case, arguing that it was successor counsel who had withdrawn claims and who had failed to pursue a default judgment against the individual defendant. The appellate court found that the record supported Vaughn-Flam’s opposition and made the rare ruling to impose sanctions on the plaintiff’s attorney.

If you think you have a legal malpractice claim, contact the Patterson Law Firm for guidance on how to pursue it.

Share the Post:

Other Related Posts

Secure Your Business Interests

Complex legal matters can be overwhelming.

Navigating insurance claims, shareholder disputes, and commercial contracts without expert guidance can lead to unfavorable outcomes.

Let our seasoned attorneys handle your legal challenges.